BE ACTIVE IN OUR CULTURAL and CIVIC AFFAIRS BETWEEN AUSTRALIA AND RUSSIA
WRITE to MELBOURNE CITY COUNCIL deploring termination of our Sister City Relationship with
ST PETERSBURG
EMAIL COUNCIL HERE com.meetings@melbourne.vic.gov.au
PRESERVE OUR SISTER CITY RELATIONSHIP WITH ST PETERSBURG VIA YOUR CULTURAL AMBASSADOR TO RUSSIA BENJAMIN SKEPPER
DEADLINE 24 FEB Council Meet 25 FEB
As your Cultural Ambassador to St. Petersburg and Russia generally,
I implore all Melbourne residents to write to City Council and express discontent at the present decision to terminate our sister city relationship with St Petersburg due to the operation of the gay propaganda laws.
This all came about through a Change.org petition, seeking signatures demanding council cut all ties with a purportedly "homophobic" sister city. Note that it is lawful to be homosexual in Russia, whereas it is not in India for example. Yet are we ceasing all trade ties with India?
Upon what grounds do Councillors and its affiliates base there assertion other than what they have noted on social media and the internet? Based on my personal discussions with Melbourne City Council, both the Business Branch and Councillors, NO RESEARCH and NO STAKEHOLDER CONSULTATION has been sought (other than a perfunctory letter to the St Petersburg City Council demanding reversal of the laws citing breaches of International Law Conventions). It appears to have been a knee-jerk emotional response to highly confronting and confounding issues, but it was certainly not based not on sound judgement through law, reason or dialogue. And what of the potentially damaging consequences to Australia's national trade interests as well as our international reputation of tolerance, understanding and mutual respect?
I was sent as a Cultural Advocate to St Petersburg in June/July 2013 at the request of The City of Melbourne. As a consultant to Council, I undertook a number of meetings with sister city counterparts and a range of public arts and civic institutions interested in the Melbourne St Petersburg relationship, to identify the level of interest in the sister city relationship and possible future projects. I provided Council with a report, which informs the future direction of cultural exchanges that may be initiated under the auspice of the Melbourne St Petersburg sister city relationship. Valuable work conducted on the ground, at a grass roots level.
As espoused by Melbourne City Council, this sister city relationship has always been about promoting ART and CULTURAL ties between our sister cities, and considering the richness of Russian cultural life and history, Australia has much to benefit from such a relationship, considering our own very young historical position. This is also about the need to provide opportunities to Australians wanting to benefit from such cultural exchange. What must be understood, this relationship was never about massive trade profits as expected with our present relations with China, India and Japan. This relationship sits within a cultural and artistic portfolio, which should not be frowned upon nor is it preclusive to benefiting our trade prospects and relationships.
Gay rights, human rights, equal rights, the entire Human Rights Debate - terminating the Sister City Relationship through Councils formal procedural system is an incorrect use of this mechanism to seek change about the gay propaganda laws. Whilst it has created debate about what we need to do in order to bring about a lasting and just result for LGBTI in Russia, it will not produce results. Terminating the relationship is going to take us further away from any lasting justice that we might seek with respect to the operation of the gay propaganda laws in Russia and indeed the anti-gay laws that still operate around Australia.
I am a trained International Lawyer with a Masters in Public and International Law focusing on Human Rights Law, specialising in Children's Rights under International Law. The present approach we are adopting will not create a debate, open up dialogue or conversation with our Russian friends. Requesting another country to change its laws (no matter how heinous they may seem) has not, and will never, work, nor is it legally justifiable under international law (and let us not forget the civilian disasters caused by military force and economic sanction regimes applied in past world conflicts and the number of people that have been injured or killed due to one political regime being "better" than the other). It is paradoxical that Australian stakeholders cite International Law Conventions when Australia's present track record is indeed abysmal, and this goes also towards Australia's treatment of homosexual people under State and Federal Criminal Law: the homosexual advances defence remains lawful (and was only repealed in Victoria 10 years ago), and the High Court recently annulled gay marriage in Canberra. So what is the solution?
How does Melbourne City Council, and its affiliated supporters and Councillors, expect that symbolically terminating the relationship is going to benefit LGBTI people in Russia when our counterparts expressly request our support? What research and understanding supports such a hypothesis?
I received a highly persuasive statement from Russia's Peak LGBTI Body Chairman
Российская ЛГБТ-Сеть (Russian LGBT Network)
"Isolation of Russia and St. Petersburg is now very bad idea. Inclusion of minorities and to discuss the problems of equality in government and civil exchanges between sister cities will be much more effective" ( Кочетков Игорь | Kochetkov Igor , председатель | chairman ) (14 December 2013, transcript email from the author)
This statement single handedly saved the relationship at Councils meeting of 17 December 2013, where our Lord Mayor Robert Doyle was essentially ready to terminate the relationship backed by our elected Councillors - I did mention the federal legal consequences of termination which had not even been considered by Council in what was to be a unilateral decision to terminate ... and so it was "competently" deferred to DFAT for advice.
I was informed that I was the only Melbourne resident to express grave concern about terminating the relationship. What do you think about this? Did you even know we had a sister city relationship with St Petersburg?
WRITE TO MELBOURNE CITY COUNIL BEFORE FEBRUARY 25 AND STATE THAT WE MUST PRESERVE OUR RELATIONSHIP WITH ST PETERSBURG
I AM YOUR CULTURAL AMBASSADOR AND I REPRESENT A FUTURE PARADIGM OF DIALOGUE AND EXCHANGE, NOT POLITICAL SYMBOLISM, VOTE GRABBING AND THE RESULTING IGNORANCE AND CONFLICTS OF INTEREST THAT UNDERPIN MUCH ABOUT THE WAY BUSINESS OPERATES.
Write in ONLINE and copy the SUBJECT HEADING
PRESERVE SISTER CITY RELATIONSHIP WITH ST PETERSBURG VIA CULTURAL AMBASSADOR TO RUSSIA BENJAMIN SKEPPER
EMAIL COUNCIL DIRECT com.meetings@melbourne.vic.gov.au
DEADLINE 24 FEB Council Meet 25 FEB to "deliberate".
THE ONLINE CONTACT LINK IS HERE
http://www.melbourne.vic.gov.au/AboutCouncil/ContactUs/Pages/ContactUs.aspx
Art and Culture can strengthen our relationships internationally, and provide an active, non-aggressive and viable way to talk about political, social and civic issues important to all humanity.
Moscow-Leningrad: Iskusstvo, 1941
No comments:
Post a Comment